Psychometric properties of the Incivility in Nursing Education - Revised Survey - Brazilian version

Ribeiro, Vanessa dos Santos; Clark, Cynthia M.; Santos, Claudia Benedita dos; Marôco, João; Alonso, Jonas Bodini; Eduardo, Aline Helena Appoloni; Carvalho, Emilia Campos de

doi:10.1590/1518-8345.6950.4215

person Vanessa dos Santos Ribeiro

Study concept and design · Obtaining data · Data analysis and interpretation · Statistical analysis · Drafting the manuscript · Critical review of the manuscript as to its relevant intellectual content · Approved the final version of the text

schoolUniversidade de São Paulo, Escola de Enfermagem de Ribeirão Preto, PAHO/WHO Collaborating Centre for Nursing Research Development, Ribeirão Preto, SP, Brazil.schoolScholarship holder at the Coordenação de Aperfeiçoamento de Pessoal de Nível Superior (CAPES), Brazil.

0000-0002-0686-4307

person Cynthia M. Clark

Study concept and design · Data analysis and interpretation · Drafting the manuscript · Critical review of the manuscript as to its relevant intellectual content · Approved the final version of the text

schoolBoise State University, School of Nursing, Boise, Idaho, ID, United States of America.

0009-0007-9049-2916

person Claudia Benedita dos Santos

Study concept and design · Data analysis and interpretation · Statistical analysis · Drafting the manuscript · Critical review of the manuscript as to its relevant intellectual content · Approved the final version of the text

schoolUniversidade de São Paulo, Escola de Enfermagem de Ribeirão Preto, PAHO/WHO Collaborating Centre for Nursing Research Development, Ribeirão Preto, SP, Brazil.schoolScholarship holder at the Conselho Nacional de Desenvolvimento Científico e Tecnológico (CNPq), Brazil.

0000-0001-7241-7508

person João Marôco

Data analysis and interpretation · Statistical analysis · Drafting the manuscript · Critical review of the manuscript as to its relevant intellectual content · Approved the final version of the text

schoolWilliam James Center for Research, ISPA - Instituto Universitário, Lisboa, Portugal.

0000-0001-9214-5378

person Jonas Bodini Alonso

Data analysis and interpretation · Statistical analysis · Drafting the manuscript · Critical review of the manuscript as to its relevant intellectual content · Approved the final version of the text

schoolUniversidade de São Paulo, Escola de Enfermagem de Ribeirão Preto, PAHO/WHO Collaborating Centre for Nursing Research Development, Ribeirão Preto, SP, Brazil.

0000-0002-5570-6081

person Aline Helena Appoloni Eduardo

Study concept and design · Data analysis and interpretation · Drafting the manuscript · Critical review of the manuscript as to its relevant intellectual content · Approved the final version of the text

schoolUniversidade Federal de São Carlos, Departamento de Enfermagem, São Carlos, SP, Brazil.

0000-0003-0691-7306

person Emilia Campos de Carvalho

Study concept and design · Data analysis and interpretation · Statistical analysis · Drafting the manuscript · Critical review of the manuscript as to its relevant intellectual content · Approved the final version of the text

schoolUniversidade de São Paulo, Escola de Enfermagem de Ribeirão Preto, PAHO/WHO Collaborating Centre for Nursing Research Development, Ribeirão Preto, SP, Brazil.

0000-0003-0738-0539

Corresponding author: Emilia Campos de Carvalho E-mail:
ecdcava@usp.br https://orcid.org/0000-0003-0738-0539

Conflict of interest:

the authors have declared that there is no conflict of interest.

Associate Editor:

Regina Aparecida Garcia de Lima

Behaviors	Item	Mean	Standard deviation	Skewness	Kurtosis
Related to students	01	2.76	0.84	-0.33	-0.45
	02	3.17	1.11	-0.94	-0.65
	03	2.87	0.82	-0.37	-0.37
	04	2.21	0.93	0.40	-0.70
	05	3.12	0.82	-0.77	0.15
	06	2.64	0.86	-0.27	-0.57
	07	2.48	0.84	-0.08	-0.60
	08	2.58	0.85	-0.01	-0.65
	09	2.49	0.92	0.10	-0.85
	10	3.08	1.01	-0.73	-0.70
	11	3.02	1.08	-0.72	-0.85
	12	3.17	0.85	-0.81	-0.01
	13	3.31	0.93	-1.13	0.12
	14	3.43	1.10	-1.56	0.61
	15	2.21	1.00	0.40	-0.90
	16	3.14	1.10	-0.94	-0.57
	17	3.05	1.12	-0.77	-0.88
	18	2.54	0.95	-0.10	-0.93
	19	3.42	1.11	-1.56	0.63
	20	3.51	1.08	-1.80	1.33
	21	3.44	1.04	-1.58	0.87
	22	3.47	1.12	-1.69	0.91
	23	3.45	1.13	-1.63	0.75
	24	3.47	1.14	-1.69	0.88
Related to faculty members	01	3.28	0.86	-1.08	0.04
	02	3.49	0.95	-1.05	-0.08
	03	3.31	0.86	-1.48	1.42
	04	3.09	0.92	-1.84	1.91
	05	3.01	0.96	-0.73	-0.33
	06	2.87	0.85	-2.23	4.02
	07	2.60	0.94	-2.40	4.48
	08	3.26	0.96	-1.56	1.87
	09	3.22	0.99	-1.49	0.97
	10	3.49	0.78	-2.74	6.71
	11	3.53	0.95	-0.91	0.16
	12	3.01	0.94	-1.82	1.49
	13	3.64	0.78	-2.01	2.21
	14	3.66	0.82	-1.87	1.73
	15	3.46	0.81	-1.88	1.58
	16	3.40	0.96	-1.86	1.56
	17	3.73	0.71	-1.88	1.60
	18	3.21	0.85	-1.08	0.04
	19	3.51	1.05	-1.05	-0.08
	20	3.57	1.01	-1.48	1.42
	21	3.53	1.02	-1.84	1.91
	22	3.53	1.08	-0.73	-0.33
	23	3.52	1.07	-2.23	4.02
	24	3.53	1.07	-2.40	4.48

Domain	Item	Factor loading	95% Confidence interval	Standard-error	Z*	P-value
High Incivility	Item13	0.734	(0.702; 0.766)	0.039	18.916	0.000
	Item 14	0.946	(0.930; 0.962)	0.016	57.785	0.000
	Item17	0.855	(0.833; 0.877)	0.023	37.411	0.000
	Item 19	0.988	(0.983; 0.993)	0.004	236.035	0.000
	Item 20	0.999	(0.997; 1.000)	0.001	1431.998	0.000
	Item 21	0.958	(0.947; 0.969)	0.011	85.421	0.000
	Item 22	0.999	(0.997; 1.000)	0.001	941.880	0.000
	Item 23	0,999	(0,997; 1.000)	0,001	1210,095	0,000
	Item 24	0.999	(0.997; 1.000)	0.001	740.119	0.000
Low Incivility	Item 1	0.149	(0.105; 0.192)	0.070	2.119	0.000
	Item 2	0.802	(0.772; 0.831)	0.032	24.995	0.000
	Item 3	0.350	(0.311; 0.388)	0.060	5.861	0.000
	Item 4	0.304	(0.261; 0.346)	0.066	4.618	0.000
	Item 5	0.290	(0.249; 0.332)	0.062	4.653	0.000
	Item 6	0.641	(0.604; 0.678)	0.043	15.021	0.000
	Item 7	0.538	(0.500; 0.576)	0.048	11.188	0.000
	Item 8	0.396	(0.354; 0.438)	0.060	6.643	0.000
	Item 9	0.577	(0.537; 0.616)	0.050	11.587	0.000
	Item 10	0.825	(0.798; 0.853)	0.028	29.948	0.000
	Item 11	0.825	(0.798; 0.852)	0.030	27.392	0.000
	Item 12	0.758	(0.728; 0.788)	0.034	22.184	0.000
	Item 15	0.299	(0.259; 0.338)	0.062	4.801	0.000
	Item 16	0.776	(0.746; 0.805)	0.036	21.609	0.000
	Item 18	0.613	(0.581; 0.644)	0.041	14.809	0.000

Domain	Item	Factor Loading	95% Confidence interval	Standard error	Z*
High Incivility	Item13	0.888	(0.870; 0.906)	0.026	33.940
	Item 14	0.963	(0.952; 0.975)	0.013	73.082
	Item17	0.948	(0.935; 0.961)	0.016	59.428
	Item 19	0.990	(0.985; 0.995)	0.004	241.701
	Item 20	0.997	(0.995; 0.999)	0.002	606.938
	Item 21	0.993	(0.989; 0.996)	0.003	313.800
	Item 22	1.000	(1.000; 1.000)	0.001	1203.589
	Item 23	0.998	(0.995; 1.000)	0.001	729.320
	Item 24	0.998	(0.996; 1.000)	0.001	739.529
Low Incivility	Item 1	0.827	(0.807; 0.848)	0.026	31.722
	Item 2	0.930	(0.914; 0.946)	0.020	47.166
	Item 3	0.674	(0.647; 0.701)	0.043	15.696
	Item 4	0.816	(0.706; 0.836)	0.029	28.355
	Item 5	0.807	(0.786; 0.827)	0.024	33.571
	Item 6	0.762	(0.739; 0.785)	0.028	26.902
	Item 7	0.709	(0.684; 0.734)	0.036	19.748
	Item 8	0.899	(0.882; 0.917)	0.018	51.310
	Item 9	0.891	(0.873; 0.909)	0.020	44.766
	Item 10	0.779	(0.756; 0.803)	0.033	23.809
	Item 11	0.937	(0.921; 0.954)	0.017	54.505
	Item 12	0.814	(0.794; 0.834)	0.026	31.101
	Item 15	0.782	(0.758; 0.805)	0.034	23.185
	Item 16	0.900	(0.883; 0.917)	0.020	45.231
	Item 18	0.596	(0.567; 0.625)	0.050	12.002

Domain	Item	Factor loading	95% Confidence interval	Standard error	Z*
High Incivility	Item13	0.734	(0.702; 0.766)	0.039	18.865
	Item 14	0.946	(0.930; 0.962)	0.016	57.844
	Item17	0.855	(0.834; 0.877)	0.023	37.411
	Item 19	0.988	(0.983; 0.993)	0.004	236.087
	Item 20	0.999	(0.997; 1.000)	0.001	1431.743
	Item 21	0.958	(0.947; 0.969)	0.011	85.376
	Item 22	0.999	(0.997; 1.000)	0.001	941.885
	Item 23	0.999	(0.997; 1.000)	0.001	1210.134
	Item 24	0.999	(0.997; 1.000)	0.001	740.191
Low Incivility	Item 2	0.801	(0.771; 0.830)	0.032	24.968
	Item 3	0.346	(0.307; 0.384)	0.060	5.768
	Item 4	0.301	(0.258; 0.343)	0.066	4.565
	Item 5	0.287	(0.246; 0.328)	0.063	4.579
	Item 6	0.640	(0.604; 0.677)	0.043	14.967
	Item 7	0.535	(0.497; 0.572)	0.048	11.058
	Item 8	0.394	(0.352; 0.436)	0.060	6.579
	Item 9	0.575	(0.536; 0.615)	0.050	11.535
	Item 10	0.825	(0.798; 0.852)	0.028	29.942
	Item 11	0.824	(0.797; 0.852)	0.030	27.339
	Item 12	0.757	(0.728; 0.787)	0.034	22.143
	Item 15	0.299	(0.259; 0.338)	0.062	4.794
	Item 16	0.775	(0.746; 0.805)	0.036	21.579
	Item 18	0.612	(0.580; 0.644)	0.041	14.791

Group of behaviors	Incivility dimensions	Items	Cronbach’s alpha value (95% CI)	Alfa ordinal value	Omega value
Students	High	13, 14, 17, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24	0.966 (0.962; 0.974)	0.984	0.976
Students	Low	2 to 12, 15, 16, 18	0.853 (0.827; 0.879)	0.880	0.857
Faculty	High	13, 14, 17, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24	0.977 (0.973; 0.981)	0.993	0.989
Faculty	Low	1 to 12, 15, 16, 18	0.949 (0.940; 0.958)	0.964	0.951

[TFN1] *Z = Standardized normal variable

Psychometric properties of the Incivility in Nursing Education - Revised Survey - Brazilian version*

Psychometric properties of the Incivility in Nursing Education - Revised Survey - Brazilian version^*